Analyzing the Impact of Transmission Strategies on Localization Performance in Wireless Sensor Networks


Creative Commons License

Turan İ. H., Yıldız D., Demirci S., Sayit M.

IEEE ACCESS, vol.13, pp.37673-37689, 2025 (SCI-Expanded) identifier

  • Publication Type: Article / Article
  • Volume: 13
  • Publication Date: 2025
  • Doi Number: 10.1109/access.2025.3545263
  • Journal Name: IEEE ACCESS
  • Journal Indexes: Science Citation Index Expanded (SCI-EXPANDED), Scopus, Compendex, INSPEC, Directory of Open Access Journals
  • Page Numbers: pp.37673-37689
  • Ondokuz Mayıs University Affiliated: Yes

Abstract

Localization, essential in WSN applications, enables sensor nodes to determine their physical positions by referencing anchor nodes. We evaluate broadcast and unicast packet transmissions at the data-link layer for their impact on localization performance. Implemented on the Contiki-NG operating system, the study examines how anchor node density and antenna range affect localization success and the number of required anchor nodes between broadcast-based and unicast-based localization propagation in protocol stack. Results using Cooja simulator, demonstrate the trade-offs between unicast and broadcast transmission approaches, particularly in terms of network overhead, energy consumption and localization performance. For instance, with an antenna range of 20 meters, achieving a localization ratio of over 90% requires only 20% anchor density with broadcast transmission, whereas unicast transmission requires a 60% anchor density to achieve the same ratio. This demonstrates that broadcast localization can lead to approximately a 33% reduction in hardware costs, offering significant efficiency gains. These findings provide insights into optimal propagation techniques and highlight the advantages of broadcasting in resource-constrained WSN deployments.

Localization, essential in WSN applications, enables sensor nodes to determine their physical positions by referencing anchor nodes. We evaluate broadcast and unicast packet transmissions at the data-link layer for their impact on localization performance. Implemented on the Contiki-NG operating system, the study examines how anchor node density and antenna range affect localization success and the number of required anchor nodes between broadcast-based and unicast-based localization propagation in protocol stack. Results using Cooja simulator, demonstrate the trade-offs between unicast and broadcast transmission approaches, particularly in terms of network overhead, energy consumption and localization performance. For instance, with an antenna range of 20 meters, achieving a localization ratio of over 90% requires only 20% anchor density with broadcast transmission, whereas unicast transmission requires a 60% anchor density to achieve the same ratio. This demonstrates that broadcast localization can lead to approximately a 33% reduction in hardware costs, offering significant efficiency gains. These findings provide insights into optimal propagation techniques and highlight the advantages of broadcasting in resource-constrained WSN deployments.